![]() |
![]() |
Starting out Surveying the field The research proposal Research methodology Research outputs Advising the novice researcher |
Research methodology Research methodology textbooks and materials Terre Blanche M. & Durrheim, K. (eds) (1999). Research in Practice: Applied methods for the social sciences. Reviewed by Caitlin Evans, Psychology Department, University of Venda.
Publisher: University
of Cape Town Press Both editors are Senior lecturers in South African Psychology
departments, Martin Terre Blanche at Unisa and Kevin Durrheim at
University of Natal. Aims as described in the preface: Research methodology, as introduced in this book, is a means to
understand the ways in which social science research produces multiple
accounts of the world. Further, '[m]ethodology specifies how the
researcher may go about practically studying whatever he or she believes
can be known' (page 6). Social research methodology is contextualised
within a comprehensive discussion of epistemology and ontology. The
different paradigms current in the social sciences (positivist,
interpretative and constructionist) are presented and illustrated
descriptively. As an introductory chapter, 'Histories of the present:
Social science research in context' (written by the editors) prepares
readers for the range of perspectives presented in the following chapters. Readers are construed as active learners, who may be entering into
careers as researchers. This impression is created especially by coverage
of areas such as: 'Publish and perish: disseminating your research
findings' (Chapter 9) and 'Jobs and careers in social science research'
(Chapter 10). In the latter chapter, aspiring researchers can see images
of a number of potential South African role models. One chapter is also
dedicated to doing an information search; another to writing and
evaluating research proposals. These are useful in providing beginner
researchers with a structure for these crucial stages in the research
process. A sense of the appeal of doing social science research is strengthened
by the diverse backgrounds of researchers who contributed chapters and
special inserts. We are given a global vision of research whilst also
being given knowledge of, and access to research currently practised in
specific contexts. The role of measurement and statistics in social science research is
treated sensitively and competently. An image of an iceberg shows the
relation between conceptualisation and operationalisation, between what is
visible and invisible. Chapter 18 is humorously entitled 'Jumping to
conclusions: An overview of inferential statistical methods'.
Interpretative paradigms are also well presented with the exception of
page 63, where some might take offence at the way in which the notion of
triangulation could suggest that the interpretative (qualitative) paradigm
is not good enough for research. A highlight of this book for me is that
it moves beyond mere inclusion of chapters about social constructionist
research. In a way, this book reveals itself as an exercise in social
constructionist methods. In a postmodern mode, exercise 3 on page 475 reads as follows: 'Go to a
social gathering (e.g. a party) and pretend to have a doctorate in
philosophy. See if you get caught out.' Although 'Research in Practice' is written in three sections, for
traditional teaching, it may be more useful to use the book across the
sections. For example, relating to quantitative research, we could read
chapters 5 and 16 (measurement and assessment), chapter 15 (sampling)
chapters 6, 17, 18 and 19 (design, data analysis and interpretation).
Chapters 7, 8, 20 and 22 are about interpretative and social
constructionist research. Critical frameworks of value-driven research
practices which aim at social transformation, and feminism, black
scholarship, Marxism and postmodernism are presented in chapters 12, 23,
and 24. Research in applied contexts (programme evaluation, public policy,
clinical settings and market/media research) are described in chapters
11,13,14 and 15. Whether this book is chosen for teaching on undergraduate or on
postgraduate level depends on the specific context. At the University of
Venda it is prescribed as a main text book on Honours (4th year) level in
the psychology department this year. As the book is used in various
contexts, the editors/authors will receive diverse feedback pertaining to
the way in which it achieves the aims identified in the preface. Naturally, the style in which the book is written varies according to
the content and author/s of each chapter. This adds to the expression of
variety of ways of being. The pictures, exposing images of humanity:
vulnerabilities, strengths... create a provocative sense, and confront us
with the dynamism of social life. Chapters are short, and accessible for
undergraduate readers. In a few places, authors have referred readers to
other chapters in the book for more information about related issues. This
contributes to a sense of consistency, against which the diversity is
displayed. The format of chapters, with outcomes in the beginning and
practical exercises at the end, also connotes the current South African
educational scenario. Different nuances of humour are found in the text.
For example, the relation between the caption 'it is more difficult to
gain entry to some cultures than to others' and photograph on page 135
evokes an ironic sense. Visual imagery, humour, and many references to the
current South African context bring the book closer to the everyday life
of students. Many creatively formulated exercises facilitate the
transferral of ideas from reading about 'Research in Practice' into living
research in practice. |
|||
|
||||